Musings, Technology and The Gospel
There has been a lot of conversation in educational circles about using online games for learning. At my university they have a games for learning initiative where they focus on using the game to teach folks educational things. One of the most popular applications is the online role playing game World of Warcraft. There are several people writing about how it teaches kids leadership and teamwork skills while still keeping them engaged. (World of Warcraft in Education Google Search)
One of the questions I have had for while is “Is there a play for Games for Learning in Spiritual Education?”
I’m not really sure what the answer is to that one. Part of me says yes, at least the game part of me. We use all sorts of games in scripture mastery classes to keep the students involved. And I bet that World of Warcraft, and other similar games, do teach the kids some good skills about teamwork and leadership. Hey, they may even provide some good missionary oppotunities, but what else are they teaching them?
Satan Twisting Things
It seems like this is just another one of Satan’s tricks. “But look at all the good it is teaching them.” I have heard similar arguments in so many different situations. How about “It was a great movie… if it weren’t for that one scene.” Yes, there is good that can happen everywhere, and I imagine someone could even say that there was some missionary work done in World of Warcraft, but how many people were lost in there too? If you look at souls lost and gained on a balance I’d wager that the lost would practically tilt the scale.
This morning I came across a GREAT article by Robert Walsh entitled “The spiritual ricks of online role-playing games.” He tells the sad story of a young man that wouldn’t go on a mission because he was so addicted to World of Warcraft. A couple of quotes:
Online gaming strikes at the heart of many issues facing families.
Technology intersects with our lives and drives business and
entertainment, he said. The biggest issues are wasting time and
compulsive behaviors.
He then goes on to lay out ways to protect our home from this harmful technology, as well signs to tell if someone you love is addicted. There are several more sad stories of this game ruining lives. Most of all we need to be vigilant and involved in our kids lives…
|
|
8 Responses for "Games for Learning in Spiritual Education?"
As someone who has been involved in making videogames for the last 20 years, I can tell you that Dr.. Knutson's observations are pretty much on target. Like many tools in the world – videogaming can be used for both good and bad purposes. I regularly give presentations to YM/YW groups about both sides of this cultural phenomenon. The bottom line – as with ANY form of entertainment – is that parents need to know and understand what it's about. Most parents don't even know about the rating system that Dr. Knutson spoke of. Just like some wouldn't let their kids watch R-rated movies…the same applies to gaming.
Let's not overlook the positive aspects of gaming. It can be used to regularly reach out to inactive or non-member youth, within the right context. It can provide a good social experience (you should have seen our Bishop playing Guitar Hero ; ). I can talk for quite awhile about the cognitive benefits of today's games…
If anyone wants to discuss this at any length – I offer my help and years of experience to any parent that wants it.
Neal. Thanks for the great comment. I appreciate your insight, and especially the idea's about how it is good. There are certainly ways it can be used to reach out to those in that world. It is just a matter of staying safe while doing that.
I would love to see any Bishop play Guitar Hero!
Reminds me of the time when our YM scheduled a gaming night where they were playing shooter games in the church. It left me with a funny feeling. Great article which I sent to a couple of family members of mine. Thanks for linking to it.
Thanks for the comment Mike. Yeah, it kind of gives me a funny feeling most of the time too. Wait… a funny feeling… could that be the spirit? Hmmm… <sarcasm>What could it be telling us?</sarcasm>
As a 22yr old member in a YSA ward, that has played WoW, and other MMO's, and a ton of games throughout the years. I would have say that, gaming, among youth is a popular, easy, and cost effective way to bring people together and have some clean fun. Yes, online-roleplaying games can suck up a huge amount of time over the long run. I have a friend that has racked up 99 days (2376hrs) of play time on WoW over the course of him playing it (about 2yrs), which is a lot of time. That would be the only downfall of playing any game, dedicating too much time to it while we could be doing something much more important with our limited time in mortality.
As far as Spiritual Education goes in relation to games, I would say there is very little ground in being taught something straight out such as “you are going to play as Noah, now go round up animals as fast as you can”. But there are virtues that can be taught in subtle ways such as, patience (Tetris), humbleness (not being a banker in Oregon Trail), and Justice (Good always triumphs), also there are always moral choices that are made which can really make you think (Star Wars: KoTOR is a good example).
MiGs, thanks for the note. I especially like how you brought out the virtues that games can teach us! I know I have learned my fair share of patience from Tetris.
MiGs, thanks for the note. I especially like how you brought out the virtues that games can teach us! I know I have learned my fair share of patience from Tetris.
[...] the dangers it presents from a spiritual perspective and wrote another article in response: “Games for Learning in Spiritual Education.” I have personally never played WoW, but I know it can be extremely [...]
Leave a reply